1. Food

Discuss in my forum

Master Forge Double Door Liquid Propane Gas Smoker

User Rating 2.5 Star Rating (2 Reviews) write a review

By , About.com Guide

Master Forge Double Door Liquid Propane Gas Smoker

Master Forge Double Door Liquid Propane Gas Smoker

GHP Group

The Bottom Line

Gas smokers afford you better control than you find in many charcoal smokers with more power than you get with electric smokers. The problem is that most gas smokers are not built well, leak smoke and heat quickly, and don't have the capacity that lets you do large racks of ribs (or even full racks some times). This Master Forge Smoker is no exception. The thin, powder coated metal box with the loose fitting doors make this a very inefficient smoker.

Pros

  • Multi-fuel smoker
  • Inexpensive tall box smoker

Cons

  • Leaks smoke and heat heavily through the doors
  • Thin, lightweight box construction

Description

  • Single 15,000 BTU cast iron burner
  • Four 200 square inch nickle plated cooking grates
  • Around 800 square inches of cooking space
  • Comes with a charcoal grate so the unit can be turned into a charcoal smoker
  • Powder coated steel construction
  • Two door design with the bottom door for accessing the wood chip and water pans
  • Made by GHP Group in China

Guide Review - Master Forge Double Door Liquid Propane Gas Smoker

Most gas smokers seem to have evolved from the kind of outdoor gas burner people use to do crab boils or fry turkeys. Cut a hole in the bottom of a metal box and place it on the burner and suddenly you have something that passes for a smoker. The question is, can these be GOOD smokers? The answer is, sometimes. A good gas smoker is low in power, well insulated and all the doors seal closed to hold in the heat and smoke. To do all this, money has to be invested. The problem, and the reason that gas smokers have gotten a bad reputation is that most of them are made with thin metal and doors that wobble closed and leak horribly. One of these is the Master Forge Double Door Smoker (oddly with the words "Liquid Propane Gas" added to the name as if that actually makes sense).

The 15,000 BTU burner is powerful enough to get this smoker up to temperature despite the fact that the doors won't fit tightly. It also has good smoke production, but when even the most ardent of fans of a product start out by telling you how to modify something to get it right, consumers should step away and look for something that was made correctly to begin with.

I do like the two doors, though that just makes the problem worse. With one door that lets you get to the food and one that lets you get to the wood chip and water pans you can hold in more heat than you would lose with one big door.

As an advertized "feature", this smoker has a folding side table that is large enough to hold a plate. In all honestly I don't find this any more than a gimmick and wish, once again, that in its place was a little thicker, stronger construction.

One last warning. The makers of this grill figured that they could give an extra grate to hold charcoal over the burner space, making this a "hybrid" smoker that runs on either liquid propane gas or charcoal. The problem with running it on charcoal is that this will accelerate the corrosion of the internal components further limiting the lifespan of the smoker. I would recommend keeping it on gas all the time. Or better yet, I would recommend looking for something better.

User Reviews

 4 out of 5
Great smoker for the price!, Member JayNH

Had this smoker for a year now and used it several times. I will say that the door does require a 3/4 inch gasket rope (wood stove rope gasket) to reduce the loss of heat and smoke. The thermometer also is not to be trusted (i don't trust any grill/smoker thermometer anyways). These are the only two minor issues I have found with this smoker. Any handy person with 20 minutes and 15 bucks can fix this rather quickly. For the price range the build of this smoker is solid. The heating element and other parts are made to last providing you cover the darn thing and clean when finished using. I also wrap the water pan with foil to extend the life. The heat is easy to control and the unit produces plenty of smoke. The unit has adjustable shelves and can hold a ton of meat. I don’t know why anyone would want to buy a small smoker considering the time and attention it takes to make a good BBQ. Having two doors is great to keep the temp from dropping and refilling the wood and water is much easier than pulling up the frame of a smaller dome smoker. I use a wireless thermometer to keep track of the temp in the unit and also in the meat. This is a small investment considering you throwing down good money and time for the meat. I have made delicious briskets, chickens, ribs and so much more in this unit with awesome results. Smoking meat is an art and many will fail if they don’t know what they are doing.

Write a review

5 out of 5 people found this helpful.
Was this review helpful to you? Yes | No

See all 2 reviews

  1. About.com
  2. Food
  3. Barbecues & Grilling
  4. Smokers
  5. Smoker Reviews
  6. Master Forge Double Door Liquid Propane - Gas Smoker Review

©2013 About.com. All rights reserved.